If you buy through links on our website, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read more

Top 10 Best Mascaras in 2021

If you are searching for the best mascaras, you are in the right place. It does not matter if you are looking for more volumized, defined, or longer lashes. We have listed the best mascaras worth adding to your makeup collection.

Reasons to look for a good mascara

Looking in the mirror, you feel like something is missing in your look. You realize that you need mascara to make your eyes pop.

There are a lot of choices for mascaras in the market. This is not surprising since this makeup product can do wonders. You can get the look you want more easily because mascara brings more attention to your eyes by giving you longer and defined lashes. What makes it more amazing is that your look can be transformed easily even if you do not have any makeup.

Best overall

Maybelline New York Lash Sensational mascara

Maybelline New York Lash Sensational mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

This mascara from Maybelline is true to its name. It is indeed sensational because it can make your looks more glamorous.  

Its magical wand is hard to ignore. The brand describes it as a lash catcher because it can capture every lash, including the lashes in your inner lid and corners. As a result, you get wider eyes. What makes the mascara better is that it has a lot to offer without having to spend much.

The brush is quite elegant. The inner bristles of the brush can cover the short inner eyelashes making your lashes more volumized. On the other hand, the outer bristles give your lashes a fan-out appearance.

Best for asian lashes

L’Oreal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes mascara

L’Oreal Paris Double Extend Beauty Tubes mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

This L’Oreal mascara has been in the market for some time, but most of us in the team have not heard of this. While reviewing customer reviews, we were pleased with what the mascara has to offer. It is a 2-step mascara that has 2 sides. One side is the primer, and the opposite side is the mascara itself.

Moreover, it is a tubing mascara. Tubing mascaras are different from regular mascaras because the former creates small tubes around your lashes to make them look fuller and longer. You can easily remove these tubes by wetting your lashes with water, and you will see the tubes sliding off.

If you are thinking of getting lash extensions at a salon, we recommend you try this mascara. Your lashes can be visibly longer up to 80% because of its lash extension action. The primer or the base coat has D-Panthenol, and Ceramide R. These ingredients are great for prepping your lashes because they protect and make the lashes stronger.  

The mascara is a great topcoat as it creates beautiful tubes that give your lashes an extended look. You will be amazed at how high, and long your lashes will be. You do not need to worry because the mascara will not smudge, flake, run, or clump. It will stay all day. Removing it is easy since you only need warm water. You do not need to rub or use a makeup remover.

Best for sensitive eyes

Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara

Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

Essence cosmetics is a famous makeup brand. You also likely know that the company makes cruelty-free products. They believe that animals do not need makeup, so they do not use them to test their products.

Aside from being long-lasting, this essence mascara does not shine or flake, so it is ideal to be worn throughout the day. Another thing to like about this budget-friendly mascara is that you do not feel you have mascara on after application.

The best feature for us is the cone-shaped fiber brush. It gives defined length and amazing volume. It has gained over 6,000 thousand reviews and earned a number 1 bestseller badge.

Best mascara that doesn’t smudge

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise mascara

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

Compared to other pricey mascaras that have standard features, the Lash Paradise mascara can compete with these. Because of its lengthening and volumizing effects, the mascara can give your lashes a full, soft, and feather-like lash fringe.

With a smooth glide formulation, there is also no clumping or flaking. You just get volumized and intense lashes because of the brush with over 200 soft and wavy bristles. You get fuller lashes because of their innovative formulation and brush. Therefore, you can easily come up with your desired makeup look.

Best for length

L’Oreal Paris Telescopic mascara

L’Oreal Paris Telescopic mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

L’Oreal claims that their telescopic lengthening mascara can make the lashes longer by up to 60%. We believe that the product can give you very long lashes. We saw many TikTok users say that this is true. The people we saw using this can compete with false eyelashes.

Many lengthening mascaras are very wet. That is why they can make the lashes look defined, but they clump easily, or they become spidery or crunchy. These are not a problem with this L’Oreal mascara. You can do multiple coatings without your lashes becoming clumpy. It is hard to find a mascara that does a great job of lengthening lashes and giving them definition and volume.

Best for volume

Maybelline New York Sky High mascara

Maybelline New York Sky High mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

This Maybelline mascara promises a sky-high effect on your lashes from different angles. It provides not only immense length but also full volume. The exclusive flex tower brush of this mascara extends and flexes. As a result, each lash can be covered from the root down to the tip.

The washable mascara also has bamboo fibers and extract to create long and full lashes that never feel heavy. It is safe for people who wear contact lenses and those with sensitive eyes. It has been tested for allergies and certified by ophthalmologists.

It is a great lengthening and long-lasting mascara, and it can define the eyes well as long as you do not apply it too much. It can look clumpy fast if you aim for very volumized lashes. We love the effect because it fans the lashes out, which lengthens them without looking too chunky.

Best affordable

Maybelline New York Great Lash Lots Of Lashes mascara

Maybelline New York Great Lash Lots Of Lashes mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

Since the launch of Great Lash mascara in 1971, it has received more awards than other Maybelline products. This is also the brand’s fastest-selling mascara.

Even though they have stopped producing the royal blue shade, this Maybelline mascara is the go-to drugstore mascara for many years. You can get it in shades that are very black and brownish-black. You can also get it in washable or waterproof variants. The waterproof variant does well in making the lashes thick and conditioned.

The brush is curved, so it builds lashes smoothly and coats them evenly without making clumps or globs. The mascara has many loyal users because of its long-lasting effect. Moreover, it is safe for people who wear contact lenses and those who have sensitive eyes.

Best for straight lashes

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume mascara

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

Covergirl is a famous makeup brand, and they are one of the most well-loved brands for mascaras. If you want the best volumizing mascara, you do not need to look any further.

There is no flaking or clumping when using the mascara. Therefore, every lash is evenly coated. We consider this feature the most defining for this product.

It also has 4 shades to choose from. You can uplift the look of your eyes with these shades. You just need to determine the shade you like. It also maxes out each lash giving your eyes a dramatic look. It promises to give 10 times more volume instantly.

Best for short lashes

Maybelline New York the Falsies Lash Lift mascara

Maybelline New York the Falsies Lash Lift mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

This Maybelline mascara is for you if you like false eyelashes but have a hard time putting them. We also recommend it for those who have short but thick lashes because of its lengthening effect.

Because of its thick fiber-infused formulation, you get your desired length, lift, and volume. The brush with 2 curves covers the lashes from the root. As a result, your lashes get the dramatic effect of falsies minus the struggle of putting them.

Moreover, the formulation does not cause your lashes to smear, clump, or flake. Therefore, you get killer lashes that last throughout the day.

Best premium

Vivienne Sabó Paris Classic French mascara

Vivienne Sabó Paris Classic French mascara

  • Ease of removing:
  • Ingredients quality:
  • Volume:
  • Value for money:
Read our full review here

Cabaret Première is a very characteristic name for mascara. We also love how sleek the tube of this mascara is. It claims to make lashes very dramatic. The smudge-proof mascara can define and volumize your lashes with a single coat. You get fanned and deep black lashes without clumps, transfer, or flaking. This is what other customers and we love most about it.

Since the brush is slightly small and has spiky bristles, it is better for lengthening than volumizing. The formulation is lightweight, and it does not become crunchy. It does not clump, smudge, or flake even when you coat it many times.

There is also no problem with smudging despite its very black shade. Even after a long day of working, you will notice that your lashes are still on point.

What’s important when choosing a good mascara

Brush

Mascaras come in many various shapes. Some mascaras have thick brushes; some have long and thin brushes and other odd shapes such as hearts. Then, you can also see curly and straight brushes. It can be a bit overwhelming, but you just need to keep in mind what your preference is.

Brushes with long bristles are ideal if you want long lashes. If you want to conceal your baby eyelashes and inner lining, you can opt for lashes with pointed tips. Small brushes are great for volume but not for lengthening. For more volumized lashes, brushes with an hourglass shape are your best choice.

Since many mascara brushes are created, We recommend that you research the type of eyelashes you have and match the right mascara brush for your needs.

Wand

You also have many choices for the length and size of your mascara wand. Some prefer a long wand because the application is not complicated for them. Nevertheless, there are some who find long wands bothersome.  

On the other hand, a short wand provides a good grip. Its length is enough to provide great coverage. This depends on how easy it is for you to handle the wand, so you have to pick carefully.

Waterproof or washable

Waterproof mascaras have rich concentration since they are made with less or no water so that sweat, tears, or rain will not wash them away. Besides being waterproof, these mascaras stick tightly on the eyelashes making your eyes look more dramatic.

Nevertheless, from its name, it is a challenge to remove them. You will not want a single eyelash to fall when you remove waterproof mascara. Because it is difficult to remove, you can use them when you have short day trips. You can have a hard time taking it off when you use it the whole day.

Washable mascaras contain high water content, so they are much easier to take off. Moreover, they are better for your eyes since they cause less damage to your soft eyelashes and inner eyelids. It is best to use washable mascara for minimal or everyday makeup, especially on the day. It does not make your eyes heavy and dry.

You do not get dramatic eyes with washable mascara, so they are not ideal for parties.

Formulation

It would help if you had mascara that can last for a day. Moreover, you have to check that it is made of quality ingredients. You have to remember that long-lasting and waterproof mascaras are different.

Many companies include paraben in their mascaras to make the product more long-lasting. However, parabens are harmful to our health. Many consumers prefer Mascaras that have long wearability and are smudge-free.

Ingredients  

Ingredients are very important in all makeup products we use. This is truer for eye makeup because eyes are sensitive organs. If you are looking for mascara to wear every day, you need to avoid mascaras with parabens.

Suppose you have sensitive eyes, you better truth mascara that is made of organic or herbal ingredients. Some harsh ingredients in mascaras make them more challenging to wash off. Even though washable mascara do not really last, they are better for people wearing contact lenses

Length and thickness of eyelashes

People who naturally have long lashes do not need to focus on this factor. Nevertheless, if you are not, you have to give much consideration to the length and thickness of your lashes.

You have a lot of choices for mascaras that give more volume and length. Do you have delicate and thin eyelashes but do not want to use eyelash extensions? Then, it would help if you used these mascaras. People who have long and thick eyelashes can opt for less concentrated mascaras because they are lightweight.

Color

There are also mascaras available in different colors if you want more drama to your eyes. This is also a great factor to consider for people who are more experimental with their looks.

Mascaras are great when you want a twist or be more adventurous with your look. Aside from black mascaras, many beauty brands offer them in blue, brown, and purple.

Taking the mascara off

When purchasing mascara, how you can safely wash it off is a very important consideration.

Unfortunately, many people neglect this factor. This is not very important if you are planning to get washable mascara because it can be easily removed.

You will likely need another product to remove the mascara for other formulations completely. We recommend getting cream or serum together with the mascara you want.

FAQ

Do mascaras really make lashes long?

Yes, it does. Mascaras have a lengthening effect. That is why your lashes look longer when you apply them.

Can anyone apply mascara?

Yes, any person can use mascara. It all boils down to choosing the right mascara for your needs or preferences, such as the length or type of eyelash you have. You just need to check the ingredients to make sure that they are safe and you are not allergic to any of them.

Can I use mascara every day?

According to the research done by Dr. Alexis Granite, Keihl’s consulting dermatologist, she found out that constantly using mascara can bring about swelling, infection, or damage to your lashes. Therefore, it is not a good idea to wear it every single day.

Final verdict

Finally, mascaras are not one-size-fits-all. It is a personal thing, so you need to research and think about the ideal mascara for you. You will want to check some factors such as the formulation, thickness, and length of your eyelashes, ingredients, and many others.

It is possible to have gorgeous lashes without having to do an eyelash extension or attach false lashes. We hope that our list can help you decide more easily what mascara to get.

OwlRatings free newsletter

Free access to breaking news, new top 10 lists, popular reviews and advice.

Absolutely no spam. Unsubscribe any time!